Unintended Consequences
by
Clare D. Coxey
Throughout my eleven years as a strategic
consultant, I have interviewed hundreds of executives, their direct reports and their employees. The interviews are part if
the data gathering segment of the process I use and most consultants use. This is where you listen to what is said and not
said, the emotion in which it is related, the body language in the moment it is said. This is where you look for the disconnects
from other interviews and commonalities. This is where you look for not only Grindl but Grindl's mother, to use the story
in Beowulf. This is where you seek out the nuances of the individuals and the culture of the client. Leaders want a strategic
plan but trust, relationship and leadership issues often stand in the way of effective strategic planning. While there are
always similarities from organization to organization it is the distinctions one sees that makes the differences on serving
the client.
Every CEO, director, manager and employee
has his or her own gifts, personality, and character and life experiences. When they all come together they form a corporate
culture. As a leader or a consultant each of the characteristics need to be nurtured, supported, enriched and cared for individually
and collectively. And they often are by leaders. And, unfortunately, they are often not, but hardly ever out of bad intention.
Leaders lead out of their life experiences, out of how they were mentored or out of what the corporate culture honors as a
"good" leader. Sometimes this produces good work and results. But then something happens and leaders look
around and ask "Is this enough?", "What more can I/we do?", "How can this organization reach the
impossible, create the improbable, be the benchmark in the world for excellence?"
What takes place in organizations is they unintentionally become self limiting. Their own
culture, although they are doing good work, limits their own possibilities in the world. It is like the gauze blanket you
see in the nurseries or in large fields during growing season. A lot of good stuff going on underneath nurtured by the blanket
but also limited by it. It is the "unintended consequences" of the corporate culture. Leaders and organization become
limited by their own actions and view of what is possible. In the nursery blanket analogy, there are often individual leaders
who try to break through the blanket. Sometimes they are successful and sometimes they are not. Occasionally organizations
honor their boldness and offer them greater responsibility and other times the are left to dry out in the sun or rot in corporate
purgatory. Also, employees sometimes take the risk and are bold in the desire for something more out of their companies. Again,
sometimes they are honored and promoted for their boldness and risk taking. Other times the are relegated to the corporate
leper colony for challenging the culture and "the way things are."
The blanket becomes heavier and heavier. And despite good intention the organization does not find the breakthrough it desires.
A poke through the blanket here and there but nothing that sustains major lifts in outcomes for the organization. Nothing
that makes the blanket lighter or removes it entirely. Nothing until a leader or group of leaders begin an inquiry about
what else is possible. The danger, unless the leaders are willing to shed old styles, old behaviors, are decisions made under
the old blanket and therefore repeat the self limiting behavior.
Leaders must start with self examination. What is it about me that should change? What is it about the leadership that needs
to change in their behavior? The paradox is the organization looks up and says "If leadership would change we could really
do something?" Leadership looks down and says "If the employees would change we could really do something."
Greater success never happens when we expect someone else to change. The flashlight must be turned on ourselves. We must change
first. This is the self responsibility of organizational breakthroughs. Knowing yourself is where organizational transformation
begins. Leadership has the greatest responsibility here because of their weighted influence in the organization.
Organizations seeking new strategic direction must start from the inquiry of how do individuals
find their natural limitless skills. How do we as an organization nurture those limitless skills? How do I as a leader uncover
my own limitless skills? How does the senior staff mine its untapped capabilities? A gauze security blanket covers individuals
as well as organizations. What often happens though is leaders are perfectly willing to deal with organization issues but
shy away from personal development because it is personal and therefore has a vulnerability to it. Transformation requires
the courage of self examination.
So what more can we
get out of work? Organizations that struggle to find the breakthrough often look in the wrong place. They look for more productivity,
better bottom line, more hours, and more customers. All critical to a business success but it is the wrong place to look.
Competence is at the core of a successful business but everyone, whether they know it or not, is seeking a greater meaning
out of work. Work has to mean more than eight hours a day plus the time they think about work work and a pay check twice a
month. Leaders and employees alike want fulfillment. Deeper meaning for what they do. I don't contend that everyone thinks
about these thing all the time. But if you have confidential, off the record interviews with employees like I do you will
see that is exactly what they want. They simply don't know quite how to express it.
So leaders, have to raise the gauze blanket, nurture themselves and nurture their employees, grow their organization to a
place they have not yet imagined, fracture the unintended consequences of their well intended culture. Organizations that
honor competence and seek fulfillment will not have to worry about productivity and the bottom line. They will be a consequence
of nurturing the limitless capacity of employees. The blanket will be lifted and the organization will thrive at levels heretofore
not thought possible.
What I passionately believe in
is human potential. I also believe leaders have a unique responsibility to nurture that potential. First by nurturing their
own gifts and then by creating the authentic environment at work so employees feel valued, enriched, inspired and committed.
This is possible in the work place. This possibility in the workplace is the competitive differentiator and the last piece
of the value proposition.